Discourse Analysis

Discourse analyses are intended to identify patterns in a collection of images and "it refers to groups of statements which structure the way a thing is thought, and the way we act on the basis of that thinking" (Rose 142). In the case of the advertising done by Victoria's Secret, this is a discourse of sexual power, or lack thereof. The variety of images used in advertising the lingerie both reinforces previously fabricated stereotypes of how the ideal woman looks as well as creates its own phenomenon of ideals, as portrayed through the Victoria's Secret Angels.

When observing the body types of all of the Victoria's Secret models, it is impossible not to notice the similarities between all of them: they are thin with long legs, flowing hair, and large breasts. By simply viewing these images not as advertisements for the lingerie that the models are wearing but as just the images themselves, "it is nearly impossible not to notice that women as represented in popular culture have gotten thinner and thinner" (Frith 227). However, it is also very apparent that in addition to the perpetuation of the thin ideal, Victoria's Secret also expects women to have full breasts, a feature uncommon among thinner women.

In addition to the previously mentioned discourse of feminine body ideals, Victoria's Secret advertising also contains a discourse of what women should be used for. Popular names for their different products include the words "sexy," "naked," and "nude," all words exemplifying the adjectives and states of being that American women are supposed to embody. Using these words and the supposedly "perfect" body types, Victoria's Secret is able to cause the audience to feel minimal and in need of their products in order to feel worthy of womanhood.

In response to these prevailing ideas as enforced by Victoria's Secret, women attempt to beautiful themselves. They buy the products, they do their hair, they try to lose weight, and the body becomes less of an object of mobility than "one of the places where the limits between what is morally acceptable and what is not, between the attractive and the repulsive, between liberation and oppression" become entirely too obvious to ignore (Thesander 9). In all of these examples of Victoria's Secret advertising, the models are attempting to accentuate their breasts but never expose all. They let their hair fly freely, but they do not always necessarily represent a woman's freedom. They encourage women to attempt to attain a nearly impossible standard of beauty by buying their products, knowing fully of the disappointments that most will experience as a result. According to Tseelon, "beauty, for the woman, is an identity claim, except that it is a conditionally spoiled identity" (Tseelon 78).

In this example of a string of Victoria's Secret advertisements, it is exemplified how the lingerie store repeats certain images with particular models' physical positioning in order to illustrate a message of what is ideal in a woman. Specifically, the Victoria's Secret Angels contribute much to this standard of beauty in advertising. When glancing down the runway at the various models of differing ethnicities, it seems nearly impossible to determine any differences between their bodies. They are virtually identical at this almost unattainable standard for women, and yet there are several of them in one place, conveying to women everywhere that this standard must be possible after all. Although these bodies are meant to model lingerie to sell for Victoria's Secret, they are embellished with jewels and wings of feathers. These features are not realistic for actual women wearing lingerie, but the Angels create an identity that is associated with Victoria's Secret lingerie: that all women will appear as glimmering angels in the lingerie that they are selling.

With all of these factors in mind, it is apparent that Victoria's Secret advertising might be considered genius. While both reinforcing stereotypes of feminine sexuality and creating its own idealistic view of women in lingerie, Victoria's Secret uses its advertising to appeal to both men and women in a variety of different ways. However, it is more difficult for audiences to determine how they are being duped into believing something that might never come true for the average woman.



Homepage Psychoanalysis Audience Studies Interpellating

Men/Women

I Love My Body

Works Cited
Frith, Katherine Toland., ed. Undressing The Ad: Reading Culture in Advertising. New York: Peter Lang, 1997. Print.

Rose, Gillian. "Visual Methodologies: An Introduction to the Interpretation of Visual Materials". 2nd ed. London: SAGE, 2007.

Thesander, Marianne. The Feminine Ideal. London: Reaktion, 1997. Print.

Tseelon, Efrat. The Masque of Femininity: The Presentation of Woman in Everyday Life. London: Sage Publications, 1995. Print.

Illustrations

Figure 1: http://www.flickr.com/photos/32143990@N00/315474076/

Figure 2: http://www.victoriassecret.com/

Elizabeth Wong

May 2, 2011